Decay predictions for #22709

From: Bjorn Gimle <Bjorn_Gimle_at_lector.kth.se>
Date: Fri, 2 Jun 1995 09:10:16 -0400
Yesterdays elset for #22709 1993-44 A :

Cosmos 2258
1 22709U 93044  A 95152.36004767  .00941474  00000-0  68337-3 0  4135
2 22709 065.0200 226.3296 0056891 241.7410 117.7956 16.11558597108051

I have tried using NPOE 3.0 integration program to predict the decay
of #22709 1993-44 A. After some trial-and-error, and many hours of
computing time, I found a value of Area*Drag coefficient/Mass of
0.02182 sq.m/kg, which makes extrapolation of elset 95148.81 to
149.25, 149.43, 149.87, 150.37, 150.49, 151.55, 152.23, 152.36
have errors of less than 4 seconds. This corresponds to an accuracy
in the drag term of better than 1%, since the accumulated effect of
drag to day 152.36 is about 540 seconds. Further extrapolation indicates
a decay on the orbit starting June 07, 17:03 UT.

The residuals show a slightly increasing tendency, both linear and
quadratic terms, which could indicate a few more revolutions are possible.

My usual mathematical extrapolation fits the given elsets to better
than 1 second for each point, but I would expect NPOE to be more
accurate for extrapolation, since it uses a real atmosphere model.

           NPOE       Day         O-C (seconds) % of drag
05/28/1995 19:34:48   148.8158308 -----------------------
05/29/1995 06:02:32   149.2517214 -3.590784      48.38%
05/29/1995 10:31:30   149.4384910 -3.982176      26.10%
05/29/1995 20:58:52   149.8742200  0.454464      -1.02%
05/30/1995 08:55:33   150.3718675 -3.195072       3.26%
05/30/1995 11:54:39   150.4962687 -1.651104       1.44%
05/31/1995 13:16:09   151.5529281   3.73248      -1.19%
06/01/1995 05:39:41   152.2359145  1.609632      -0.32%
06/01/1995 08:38:26   152.3600477  2.439936      -0.45%

You can compare the following predicted node crossings with future
elsets, to judge the accuracy of my NPOE attempt:

				    Semi-major axis :
06/01/1995 10:07:47   152.4220747
06/01/1995 11:37:08   152.4841245   6626.5778
06/01/1995 13:06:29   152.5461694   6626.231
06/01/1995 14:35:49   152.6082095   6625.8817
06/01/1995 16:05:09   152.6702446   6625.5296
06/01/1995 17:34:29   152.7322747   6625.1749
06/01/1995 19:03:48   152.7942999   6624.8174
06/01/1995 20:33:06   152.8563200   6624.4571
06/01/1995 22:02:24   152.9183349   6624.094
06/01/1995 23:31:42   152.9803448   6623.7279
06/02/1995 01:00:59   153.0423495   6623.3594
06/02/1995 02:30:16   153.1043490   6622.9879
06/02/1995 03:59:32   153.1663433   6622.6134
06/02/1995 05:28:48   153.2283322   6622.2356
06/02/1995 06:58:03   153.2903159   6621.8547
06/02/1995 08:27:18   153.3522941   6621.4705
06/02/1995 09:56:33   153.4142669   6621.0829
06/02/1995 11:25:47   153.4762343   6620.6918
06/02/1995 12:55:00   153.5381961   6620.2972
06/02/1995 14:24:13   153.6001523   6619.8991
06/02/1995 15:53:26   153.6621030   6619.4973
06/02/1995 17:22:38   153.7240479   6619.0917
06/02/1995 18:51:49   153.7859871   6618.6822
06/02/1995 20:21:00   153.8479206   6618.2688
06/02/1995 21:50:11   153.9098482   6617.8514
06/02/1995 23:19:21   153.9717699   6617.4299
06/03/1995 00:48:30   154.0336856   6617.0047
06/03/1995 02:17:39   154.0955953   6616.5754
06/03/1995 03:46:48   154.1574990   6616.1416
06/03/1995 05:15:56   154.2193966   6615.7034
06/03/1995 06:45:03   154.2812879   6615.2605
06/03/1995 08:14:10   154.3431730   6614.8128
06/03/1995 09:43:16   154.4050518   6614.3602
06/03/1995 11:12:22   154.4669242   6613.9026
06/03/1995 12:41:27   154.5287901   6613.4398
06/03/1995 14:10:32   154.5906495   6612.9718
06/03/1995 15:39:36   154.6525022   6612.4983
06/03/1995 17:08:40   154.7143483   6612.0192
06/03/1995 18:37:43   154.7761876   6611.5343
06/03/1995 20:06:45   154.8380200   6611.0435
06/03/1995 21:35:47   154.8998455   6610.5466
06/03/1995 23:04:48   154.9616640   6610.0434
06/04/1995 00:33:48   155.0234754   6609.5342
06/04/1995 02:02:48   155.0852796   6609.0187
06/04/1995 03:31:47   155.1470765   6608.4964
06/04/1995 05:00:46   155.2088660   6607.9669
06/04/1995 06:29:44   155.2706480   6607.4302
06/04/1995 07:58:41   155.3324225   6606.8859
06/04/1995 09:27:38   155.3941892   6606.3338
06/04/1995 10:56:34   155.4559481   6605.7737
06/04/1995 12:25:29   155.5176991   6605.2051
06/04/1995 13:54:24   155.5794421   6604.6279
06/04/1995 15:23:18   155.6411769   6604.0418
06/04/1995 16:52:11   155.7029034   6603.4463
06/04/1995 18:21:03   155.7646215   6602.8412
06/04/1995 19:49:55   155.8263311   6602.2261
06/04/1995 21:18:46   155.8880319   6601.6005
06/04/1995 22:47:36   155.9497239   6600.9641
06/05/1995 00:16:26   156.0114069   6600.3166
06/05/1995 01:45:14   156.0730807   6599.6583
06/05/1995 03:14:02   156.1347452   6598.9876
06/05/1995 04:42:49   156.1964002   6598.3043
06/05/1995 06:11:35   156.2580455   6597.6076
06/05/1995 07:40:20   156.3196810   6596.897
06/05/1995 09:09:05   156.3813064   6596.1717
06/05/1995 10:37:48   156.4429215   6595.4312
06/05/1995 12:06:31   156.5045261   6594.6746
06/05/1995 13:35:13   156.5661200   6593.9011
06/05/1995 15:03:54   156.6277030   6593.1098
06/05/1995 16:32:33   156.6892747   6592.3
06/05/1995 18:01:12   156.7508349   6591.4704
06/05/1995 19:29:50   156.8123834   6590.6199
06/05/1995 20:58:27   156.8739198   6589.7473
06/05/1995 22:27:02   156.9354438   6588.8513
06/05/1995 23:55:37   156.9969551   6587.9305
06/06/1995 01:24:10   157.0584534   6586.9843
06/06/1995 02:52:43   157.1199382   6586.0099
06/06/1995 04:21:14   157.1814091   6585.0054
06/06/1995 05:49:44   157.2428658   6583.9684
06/06/1995 07:18:12   157.3043077   6582.8966
06/06/1995 08:46:39   157.3657344   6581.7872
06/06/1995 10:15:05   157.4271452   6580.6372
06/06/1995 11:43:30   157.4885397   6579.4429
06/06/1995 13:11:53   157.5499171   6578.2006
06/06/1995 14:40:14   157.6112769   6576.9055
06/06/1995 16:08:34   157.6726181   6575.5525
06/06/1995 17:36:52   157.7339400   6574.1355
06/06/1995 19:05:09   157.7952416   6572.6472
06/06/1995 20:33:23   157.8565219   6571.0792
06/06/1995 22:01:36   157.9177796   6569.4214
06/06/1995 23:29:47   157.9790136   6567.6615
06/07/1995 00:57:55   158.0402222   6565.7859
06/07/1995 02:26:01   158.1014038   6563.7744
06/07/1995 03:54:05   158.1625563   6561.6034
06/07/1995 05:22:06   158.2236773   6559.2414
06/07/1995 06:50:04   158.2847638   6556.6469
06/07/1995 08:17:58   158.3458124   6553.7615
06/07/1995 09:45:49   158.4068185   6550.5019
06/07/1995 11:13:36   158.4677761   6546.7391
06/07/1995 12:41:18   158.5286772   6542.2569
06/07/1995 14:08:54   158.5895095   6536.6446
06/07/1995 15:36:22   158.6502528   6528.9288
06/07/1995 17:03:39   158.7108638   6515.2542

My usual method gives Ascending Node Times as
155.7665589 -0.0604255504*x -0.000324220662,*x*ln(x)
where x= 10860.18650873 -n , and n is an integer orbit number.
Although this fits the current elsets better, the .000324 value,
which is roughly proportional to atmosperic scale height, has been
about .00055 for most successful extrapolations (.0004-.0005 for
the very last days). This fully explains the (asymptotic) decay
date of 155.96, almost three days before the NPOE model prediction.

=========================================================
Bjorn_gimle@lector.kth.se == bjorn.gimle@duesenberg.se ==
== bjorn.gimle@online.dextel.se ;  59.22371 N, 18.22857 E
=========================================================
Received on Fri Jun 02 1995 - 09:07:56 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0 : Fri Mar 07 2014 - 00:14:45 UTC